We can’t be capable of reply definitively whether or not this strategy is “too restrictive” — that can at all times be a judgment name that you must make because the creator of the sport. However we are able to counsel methods that will help you assess that, or suggest options you may weigh.
Firstly: any friction in video games will at all times generate some complaints. And any login wall will lose you some fraction of your customers. As one level of reference: final yr, I obtained into taking part in every day puzzles on Puzzmo. Despite the fact that it turned a part of my every day routine and I believed nicely of the positioning, I did not create an account till after I would been taking part in for a number of months: the mistrust/annoyance barrier was simply that top, and my stage of dedication to a browser-based puzzle assortment was that low, regardless of frequent and pleasurable play.
The query is whether or not this restriction serving a objective that offers sufficient profit to justify that frustration. If the aim is actually simply to persist progress, we are able to discover lower-impact methods to help that (see under). If not, consider what advantages you achieve from authentication…
-
Are you hoping to create extra loyalty and long-term participant retention by way of the creation of an account relationship?
-
Are you wanting to make use of actual usernames to make aggressive options like leaderboards extra compelling?
and so forth.
As soon as you already know what you are attempting to get out of it, you may collect some knowledge to evaluate how nicely the authentication system is serving that purpose (e.g. what does the retention sample or leaderboard view/problem exercise seem like for authenticated versus non-authenticated customers)? Then distinction that towards how a lot the frustration is detracting from it (how giant a drop-off do you observe at stage 6 once you require authentication)?
This can assist you make an evidence-based evaluation of whether or not the function is contributing to a internet win to your targets, fairly than relying wholly on subjective emotions or opinions from gamers or different Web strangers like us.
However say you wish to be much less restrictive – how might you try this with out risking lack of progress that would flip gamers off simply as badly? (And with out simply storing progress regionally the place it may very well be manipulated)
One choice could be to generate a singular random “authentication token” for every person mechanically after they first go to. Retailer that authentication token in native storage, and in a persistent server-side database.
Every time an unauthenticated participant makes progress, file that progress within the database row matching their token. Once they begin a brand new sport session, load their progress from that database and use that to initialize the session.
As a result of it is saved in a database, it could actually persist throughout a number of server periods. And since the tokens are simply random bits, modifying what’s saved regionally would not let the participant achieve any benefit: all they’d do is corrupt their token and reset to zero progress, except they handle to completely guess another person’s token (and you’ll select a variety of bits that makes this astronomically unlikely).
When a participant does create a login, you switch their progress to your authenticated customers desk, linked to that login, to allow them to proceed from the place they left off. If you wish to present them on leaderboards within the meantime, you may present them as “You” to themselves, and optionally generate a placeholder username to indicate to different gamers (like Google Docs’ “nameless giraffe” and co).
This does imply spending some storage on gamers who go to as soon as after which by no means once more. To maintain this from getting out of hand, you may retailer the final entry time with every token, and periodically wipe database rows that have not been utilized in some interval like 30 days or 3/6/12 months, as you want.
The participant can nonetheless lose progress by clearing native storage (or taking part in in an in-private/incognito window), altering units, and so forth., however that is on them. And you may promote this as a perk of registering: get cross-device play and guarded development. That is perhaps perceived as a sweeter provide than a login wall.
